How well do kindergarten assessments predict third-grade test scores? Evidence from Michigan
Nationally, 45 states and DC require student assessments prior to third grade. We examine how well three assessments used to measure children's skills in kindergarten—the Kindergarten Readiness Assessment (KRA), NWEA, and i-Ready—predict third-grade test scores in Michigan. Our findings help illuminate the importance of strong kindergarten skills and can inform assessment choices in the early years in Michigan and beyond.
Key findings
- The KRA, NWEA, and i-Ready assessments predicted third-grade reading and math skills. For example, students who scored one standard deviation higher on the spring math NWEA were 21 percentage points more likely to be proficient in math in third grade.
- KRA and NWEA scores were more predictive than i-Ready scores.
- Assessments were similarly predictive for economically disadvantaged children and their non-economically disadvantaged peers.
Our descriptive findings show that kindergarten assessments provide an early signal of children's trajectories in their critical elementary school years. Our findings are highly relevant in Michigan, where districts use a patchwork of assessment tools and state assessment policy continues to evolve.
More broadly, our findings can help inform state and district leaders—in Michigan and elsewhere—as they consider which assessments to adopt and how to interpret early assessment data to support students most effectively.